Links:                                                                                                         
My home page                                                                                                                                                                                                      

David Mease's Football Rankings


Below are my ranks for all 120 Division 1-A teams based on all games played for the 2009-2010 season including the bowl games.  The ranks were produced using a penalized maximum likelihood model I have developed which is described in a paper I recently wrote.  The model uses ONLY wins and losses as its input and ignores margin of victory, location of the game, conference affiliation, date of the game, etc.  Moreover, the model does not use any prior information such as pre-season rankings. Despite its simplicity, the rankings produced have agreed more strongly on average with the AP and Coaches polls than all 10 computer models that have been used in the BCS, as discussed in my paper.

Click here to download my paper, updated July of 2003.  The paper was published in the November 2003 issue of The American Statistician.

Click here to view the SAS code or R code which ranks teams using my model.


Special thanks to Derek, Vijay, and Earl for all the help they have given me with this project and to Kenneth Massey for including my rankings on his comparison page.

 

 

Rank

Team

Rating

Wins

Losses

1

Alabama

2.0435

14

0

2

Florida

1.6840

13

1

3

Boise St.

1.5953

14

0

4

Texas

1.4950

13

1

5

Cincinnati

1.4501

12

1

6

TCU

1.3603

12

1

7

Iowa

1.0954

11

2

8

Ohio St.

1.0832

11

2

9

Oregon

1.0464

10

3

10

Brigham Young

0.9975

11

2

11

Penn St.

0.9789

11

2

12

Virginia Tech

0.9468

10

3

13

Georgia Tech

0.9274

11

3

14

LSU

0.8458

9

4

15

Pittsburgh

0.8079

10

3

16

Utah

0.7608

10

3

17

Wisconsin

0.7529

10

3

18

USC

0.6817

9

4

19

Central Michigan

0.6782

12

2

20

Miami, Fla.

0.6719

9

4

21

West Virginia

0.6607

9

4

22

Nebraska

0.6489

10

4

23

Arkansas

0.6422

8

5

24

Mississippi

0.6111

9

4

25

Oklahoma St.

0.6069

9

4

26

Georgia

0.5665

8

5

27

Arizona

0.5450

8

5

28

Auburn

0.5376

8

5

29

Oregon St.

0.5310

8

5

30

Oklahoma

0.5003

8

5

31

Texas Tech

0.4946

9

4

32

Clemson

0.4889

9

5

33

Connecticut

0.4566

8

5

34

Stanford

0.4301

8

5

35

Rutgers

0.4186

9

4

36

Navy

0.4027

10

4

37

California

0.3927

8

5

38

Florida St.

0.3781

7

6

39

South Carolina

0.3649

7

6

40

Tennessee

0.3620

7

6

41

North Carolina

0.3602

8

5

42

Houston

0.3515

10

4

43

Troy

0.3414

9

4

44

South Florida

0.3396

8

5

45

East Carolina

0.3187

9

5

46

Middle Tennessee

0.3045

10

3

47

Boston College

0.3037

8

5

48

Missouri

0.2878

8

5

49

Air Force

0.2607

8

5

50

UCLA

0.2436

7

6

51

Kentucky

0.2305

7

6

52

Northwestern

0.2043

8

5

53

Fresno St.

0.1978

8

5

54

Mississippi St.

0.1890

5

7

55

Central Fla.

0.1651

8

5

56

Notre Dame

0.1347

6

6

57

Nevada

0.1194

8

5

58

Washington

0.0784

5

7

59

Wyoming

0.0630

7

6

60

SMU

0.0624

8

5

61

Idaho

0.0503

8

5

62

Minnesota

0.0448

6

7

63

Iowa St.

0.0110

7

6

64

Texas A&M

-0.0244

6

7

65

Ohio U.

-0.0250

9

5

66

Michigan St.

-0.0293

6

7

67

Temple

-0.0634

9

4

68

Marshall

-0.0722

7

6

69

Bowling Green

-0.0790

7

6

70

Kansas St.

-0.1222

6

6

71

Purdue

-0.1368

5

7

72

So. Mississippi

-0.1825

7

6

73

Wake Forest

-0.1841

5

7

74

North Carolina St.

-0.2398

5

7

75

Kansas

-0.2451

5

7

76

Syracuse

-0.2517

4

8

77

Nevada Las Vegas

-0.2587

5

7

78

Louisville

-0.2872

4

8

79

Baylor

-0.2889

4

8

80

Hawaii

-0.3032

6

7

81

Arizona St.

-0.3065

4

8

82

No. Illinois

-0.3377

7

6

83

UAB

-0.3386

5

7

84

Michigan

-0.3418

5

7

85

La. Lafayette

-0.3786

6

6

86

La. Monroe

-0.3923

6

6

87

Florida Atlantic

-0.5041

5

7

88

Colorado

-0.5231

3

9

89

Duke

-0.5289

5

7

90

Tulsa

-0.5353

5

7

91

La. Tech

-0.5446

4

8

92

Utah St.

-0.5551

4

8

93

Buffalo

-0.5607

5

7

94

San Diego St.

-0.5745

4

8

95

Indiana

-0.5821

4

8

96

Illinois

-0.5902

3

9

97

Toledo

-0.6393

5

7

98

Virginia

-0.6612

3

9

99

Texas El Paso

-0.6972

4

8

100

Kent

-0.7059

5

7

101

Colorado St.

-0.7551

3

9

102

Army

-0.7576

5

7

103

Arkansas St.

-0.8319

4

8

104

Western Michigan

-0.8394

5

7

105

Vanderbilt

-0.8756

2

10

106

Tulane

-0.8765

3

9

107

Maryland

-0.8777

2

10

108

Washington St.

-0.8961

1

11

109

Florida Intl

-0.9013

3

9

110

Rice

-0.9729

2

10

111

Akron

-1.0124

3

9

112

Memphis

-1.0174

2

10

113

San Jose St.

-1.0402

2

10

114

New Mexico St.

-1.0544

3

10

115

New Mexico

-1.2217

1

11

116

Miami, Ohio

-1.2515

1

11

117

North Texas

-1.3486

2

10

118

Ball St.

-1.4308

2

10

119

Eastern Michigan

-1.8917

0

12

120

Western Kentucky

-1.9403

0

12